Last week, I asked a big question: Is Christianity evolving? There are some who think it should. Progressive Christianity is a new movement among some of the mainstream Protestant denominations.
In last week’s blog (which I highly recommend you read), I shared what I found about the eight main pillars of the Progressive Christian movement and held four of the pillars up to the Bible—the gold standard—to see if its tenets line up with God’s Word. Today, let’s continue by examining the remaining four pillars.
The Remaining Four Pillars of Progressive Christianity
5. Progressive Christians believe we should find grace in the search for understanding and believe there is more value in questioning than in absolutes. Let’s look at this in two parts. First, as we’re trying to find answers, there should be grace. Who can argue with this? But they should have left it at that. The second part of the statement, well, I wouldn’t quite agree with that. The first thing I notice about this fifth pillar is that it sets understanding and belief (or acceptance) against each other as absolutes or dogma. This is a common mistake in culture today and assumes a fallacy right out of the gate that truth is relative. It’s not. Truth is truth.
First of all, debate is not kindness versus abrasiveness—or shouldn’t be with Christians. Truth tellers need not, and should not, be abrasive, aggressive, or antagonistic right out of the gate, especially as we’re seeking to convey God’s truth. See, it’s not grace OR truth. It’s not truth without grace. It’s truth AND grace. It has to be, or people won’t listen.
More importantly, there are many truths that are difficult to hear, especially if what we’ve been indoctrinated with is lies (as is practically a requirement of most universities and college campuses today).
6. We need to strive for peace and justice among all people. This is another one that, on the surface, who can argue with that? Not me; I love it. However, there is something to be said here first. Our primary mission as Christians is to introduce people to the Prince of Peace, not claim to be the Prince of Peace. Jesus Christ is the only reason we can truly live peacefully with God. Jesus Christ is called the Prince of Peace because He restores every broken relationship. He provides a well-ordered and balanced life. He offers the assurance of eternal life.And this was predicted as one of the attributes of the coming Messiah hundreds of years before Jesus was born. Isaiah 9:6 says, “For to us a child is born, to us a Son will be given, and the government shall be upon his shoulders, and he will be called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace.” So, any peaceful solution that doesn’t ultimately rest on Jesus and the truth of His Word is a band-aid at best and further contributes to division and hostility at worse.
7. Strive to protect and restore the integrity of our Earth. This is a bit of a straw man. We are commanded to be stewards over God’s creation. It’s not even an option. However, it’s not THE mission for Christ Followers that it’s often presented as today. Far too many Christians forego the Great Commission in favor of being SJWs or advocates for climate reform. We need to be faithful and honoring advocates for this beautiful planet God gave us to live upon. However, Christ Followers know how the story ends, and we do eternal damage when we make this temporary life and its betterment the primary mission to the exclusion of the eternal question ultimately answered only in repentance and faith in Jesus Christ. Where are we going to spend eternity? In hell separated from Him, or in Heaven with Him, through the reconciliation as I said earlier provided only in Jesus Christ.Now, you might be thinking, why does it have to be one or the other? Can’t we be good stewards of the environment and faithful missionaries too? You know what? That’s a good question, but perhaps a better one is why is it Progressive Christians are so often the ones who abandon the latter in favor of the former? (Ponder that…)
8. Commit to a path of life-long learning, compassion, and selfless love on this journey toward a personally authentic and meaningful faith. Sounds good. I like that. I agree…so long as the path toward life-long learning doesn’t first seek to alter (or throw out altogether) the perfect textbook of God’s Word in said quest. However, altering God’s word is the very premise and foundation of a lot of Progressive Christianity because adherence begins with the conviction that God is old-fashioned, and His word needs constant human intervention and updating, which, for a perfect and unchanging God, it obviously doesn’t.
So, what do you think? Do you think the pillars of Progressive Christianity line up with the Word of God? Do you believe that God’s Word needs to be updated by humans to make it more relevant to the current times? I surely don’t.
Until next time, Peace!
~Pastor Rob
Aka P-Ro